Crack Myths: What Really Causes Tile to Break or Shift Over Time
When it comes to home flooring and installations, tiles are often celebrated for their durability, aesthetic appeal, and low maintenance requirements. But for many homeowners, finding a cracked tile or noticing a floor that seems to have mysteriously shifted over time is both frustrating and puzzling. What caused it? Was it something you did, or is there a mysterious "tile curse"?
This blog dives into the common myths surrounding cracked and shifting tiles and uncovers the real reasons behind these issues. Whether you're a homeowner, contractor, or simply a fan of DIY home improvement, we’ll help you understand the key factors involved and how to avoid tile trouble in the future.
Common Myths About Tile Cracking and Shifting
Before we get into the real causes, it’s time to bust some common myths about why tiles crack or move. Believing these misconceptions can lead to confusion and improper maintenance practices:
Myth 1: "Cheap Tiles Crack Easily"
Many people assume that lower-cost tiles are more likely to crack. While material quality plays a role in durability, even high-quality tiles can break under the right (or wrong) conditions. The key takeaway is that tile damage often has more to do with improper installation or underlying structural issues than price alone.
Myth 2: "Extreme Temperature Changes Cause Cracking"
Tiles are typically designed to withstand reasonable temperature fluctuations. Unless you're talking about extreme conditions (like firing up a fireplace next to your tile flooring without proper thermal insulation), temperature changes are rarely the sole cause of cracking.
Myth 3: "It’s Always the Installer’s Fault"
Pointing fingers at the installer is common, but they’re not always to blame for cracking or shifting tiles. Sometimes, the problems stem from underlying structural movement, the wrong adhesive being used, or even poor-quality subfloor preparation.
Myth 4: "All Cracks Mean You Need New Tiles"
Not necessarily! Some cracks are surface-level and can be repaired without having to replace the entire tile or re-lay your flooring. Identifying the type of crack is essential to determine the best solution.
Now that we’ve cleared up a few myths, let's turn our attention to the real culprits.
What Really Causes Tile to Crack or Shift?
1. Improper Subfloor Installation
One of the most common causes of tile damage lies beneath the tile itself. Tiles are rigid and depend entirely on the stability of the subfloor for support. If the subfloor isn’t properly leveled, gaps may form underneath the tile, resulting in pressure points that cause cracks over time. Common subfloor issues include:
- Uneven Surfaces: If the surface wasn't leveled before installation, tiles may settle unevenly, leading to cracks or loose tiles.
- Unsecured Subflooring: Over time, movement in a subfloor that wasn’t properly fastened can transfer forces to the tiles, causing them to pop or shift.
2. Expansion and Contraction of Materials
Tiles, grout, and adhesive need room to “breathe.” If there aren’t sufficient expansion joints (small gaps that allow for natural movement in response to temperature or humidity changes), pressure builds up and tiles may crack or lift.
Pro Tip: Always ensure your installer includes expansion joints, particularly in larger tiled areas or areas exposed to changes in temperature, such as patios or sunrooms.
3. Incorrect Adhesive or Grout Use
Using the wrong type of adhesive or grout for the specific tile material and location is a common oversight. For instance, outdoor tiles require freeze-thaw-resistant materials, while tiles in wet areas (like showers) need waterproof adhesive to maintain adhesion over time. If an installer uses basic materials where specialized ones are needed, you could see cracking, shifting, or even water damage.
4. Heavy Impacts
No matter how strong your tiles are, they’re not invincible. Dropping heavy objects, dragging furniture, or accidentally using tools that scratch or chip tiles can leave them vulnerable to deeper damage over time. If a tile gets damaged on the surface, it’s more susceptible to further cracking from even minor pressure.
5. Structural Movement in the Building
If your home’s structure shifts or settles unevenly, it creates pressure on the tiles. These movements can be small and gradual (think foundation settling), but they’re enough to push tiles out of alignment, create cracks, or cause grout to crumb. This is particularly common in older homes or areas prone to earthquakes.
6. Poor Tiling Practices
Last but certainly not least, improper tile installation remains a primary reason for cracking and shifting. Examples include:
- Insufficient Adhesive: If the adhesive doesn’t fully cover the back of the tile, voids can form, making them prone to cracking under pressure.
- Rushed Grout Application: Grouting too soon before the adhesive has cured can weaken the bond.
- Incorrect Tile Alignment: Even slight misalignments during installation can cause uneven stress on tiles, making them more likely to shift or wear prematurely.
How to Prevent Tiles from Cracking or Shifting
Now that you know the causes, here are practical steps to ensure your tiles remain intact and stable for years to come:
1. Choose Professional Installers
While DIY tiling might seem tempting, it’s worth investing in experienced professionals who understand the nuances of tile installation, including subfloor preparation, adhesive use, and proper alignment.
2. Prepare the Subfloor Properly
Start with a clean, level, and secure subfloor. Use leveling compounds and ensure there’s no debris that could interfere with proper adhesion.
3. Use the Right Materials
Select adhesive, grout, and underlayment suited to your tile type and environment. Don’t cut corners here—using the wrong materials can cause costly damage down the road.
4. Allow for Expansion
Make sure you or your installer includes expansion joints in tiled areas, particularly for outdoor installations.
5. Avoid Dragging Heavy Items
When moving furniture or appliances across a tiled surface, use protective pads or lift them entirely to avoid scratches or cracks.
6. Regularly Inspect and Maintain
Catch potential problems early by inspecting tiles, grout, and surrounding areas for any signs of cracking, loosening, or water damage.
What To Do If You've Got Cracked or Shifted Tiles
If you’re already dealing with cracked or shifting tiles, don’t panic. Depending on the extent of the damage, there are several fixes available:
- For Minor Cracking: Use an epoxy tile repair kit to fill surface-level cracks.
- For Loosened Tiles: Remove the affected tile, clean the area, and reset it using fresh adhesive and grout.
- For Widespread Issues: Call in a professional to assess and address deeper structural or installation problems.
Keep Tiles in Top Shape for Years to Come
Tiles are designed to be durable, beautiful, and long-lasting, but proper installation and maintenance are key to preventing cracks and shifts over time. By investing in careful preparation and using the right materials, you can enjoy your tiled surfaces without worrying about unexpected damage.
For more tips on maintaining tiled surfaces or finding trusted professionals in your area, leave us a comment below or contact our team directly. Here's to tiles that stand the test of time!
We serve Austin, Round Rock, Cedar Park, Pflugerfille, West Lake Hills, Bee Cave, Manor, Sunset Valley, Manchaca, Buda, Hornsby Bend, Hudson Bend
Tile contractors, Tile contractor, Bathroom remodel Austin, Tile installers
Tile Installation Pros Austin
Austin, TX 78744
512-312-7956